Speaking before the committee meeting, Cr Snedden said the beach would attract Melbourne families who could not afford to take holidays, or those who simply wanted to go to a local beach, without having to travel across town.
"To have an urban beach right on your back door would be very exciting," she said. "It would be for me - I'd be going there every day."
It still requires people travelling INTO the centre of Melbourne, which can take over an hour on public transport to then sit on a fake beach, next to a river they cannot swim in, when, if they travel just a teeny bit more, they can be lazing on a beach and swimming in Port Philip Bay.
Cr Fraser Brindley argued against the move, saying it would be a waste of money "trying to put nature where nature didn't put itself".
"My antiquated, conservative point of view is that if you want to go to the beach, you go to the beach; if you want to go to the forest, you go to the forest; if you want to walk beside the river, you walk beside the river," he said.
This antiquated, non-conservative agrees.
It has been a year of valuable life lessons: don't make Russell Crowe angry, don't smuggle drugs into South-East Asia and don't make a man who keeps a diary the leader of your political party. We saw what happens when you make the right life choices (marrying a Danish prince, being an arch-conservative right-hand man to an ageing Pope), and we saw what happens when you make the wrong life choices (Big Brother, Australian Princess, Big Brother Up Late, Aussie Queer Eye For The Straight Guy, Big Brother: Friday Night Live, Big Brother Uncut, etc.)Tsunami
As the New Year arrived, the world was still struggling to cope with the devastation of the Boxing Day tsunami. The disaster killed hundreds of thousands in Indonesia, Thailand andThe Pope
Sri Lanka, but more importantly a handful of Australians.
In May, Pope John Paul II lost his protracted struggle to remain alive until he finished reading The Da Vinci Code. His death came as an enormous shock to Catholics, who thought he had died some time in 1993.Charles and Camilla
The new Pope, Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, chose the name Pope Benedict XVI after having had trouble obtaining Hotmail addresses for Pope Benedicts I to XV.
After years searching for a wife who James Hewitt wouldn't want to have an affair with, Prince Charles finally married Camilla Parker-Bowles in April. Charles and Camilla have been in love for decades but delayed their wedding until 2005, so no one would have to worry about them breeding.The Ashes
Finally, the day concluded in the same way Charles' first wedding did, with him spending the night with Camilla.
The loss of the Ashes was devastating to Australians still reeling from England winning the Rugby World Cup in 2003. But, as Australians always say when they lose, cricket was the winner in the Ashes of 2005. So the Poms should stop gloating.Princess Mary
Besides, losing has been good for Australia. After all those years of winning too easily, Australians can now return to the great Aussie tradition of being sore losers.
Princess Mary made her one useful contribution to her adopted nation of Denmark this year, with the birth of a male heir to the throne. The Danish people initially reacted with enormous excitement but, after the first week had passed, were already putting pressure on the new prince to settle down and begin having children. The news drew a crowd of Australian women in low-cut dresses to the maternity ward in the hope of seducing Europe's newest royal heir.